TIGblogs TIG | TIGblogs GROUP TIGBLOGS LOGIN SIGNUP
Corner Of Helena Rijoly's World
Corner Of Helena Rijoly's World
What's wrong with TIG's Nationality Entry??????

Immediately after I Sign up to TIG, I was determined to complete my profile.
Then I stumbled on a disturbing choice I have to make.
Nationality ...?
Because I'm an Indonesian, I know I will choose Indonesian but the bracketed informationbehind it make me frowned.
TIG had made the choice to appear ... (incl Javanese/Sundanese/Sumatran)
ding ... ding .. !!!
What is that supposed to mean.... to my shallow mind it might meant

It is not sure whether Javanese/Sundanese/Sumatran are Indonesian therefore we need to have this prompt to make sure / acknowledge / encourage that they are part of Indonesia. This is very silly to me. As it become bias to me. I suppose that Indonesia mean Sabang (in Sumatra) and Merauke (in Papua). Why should an International site such as TIG make such emphasize?

Is it that Javanese/Sundanese/Sumatran have different nationality?
Would they claim that their nationality is that other of Indonesian??
Then what would it be?
This very small line make me wonder? Why does it introduce such confusing and bias ideas
this is like in a classroom when a teacher is talking and giving instruction and said,
"This class is required to submitt a one page essay on TIG", ]
then the teacher added, "that include the three of you... Jack, Sandra and Sam"

Well... to me ... something is not feeling right with this entry.

We are approaching April 25th, and in my place Ambon - Maluku province, that date is acknowledge as one of the separatism group Independence Anniversary (South Maluku Republic). on April 25th 2004, a big conflict occured and killed many prople as well as devastaed people's life, destroying houses and public facilities. And not just that we have just come out from 5 years of bloody conflict. We are still in post conflict period with all of it's long lasting effects.

Now just for a thought, East Timor, Aceh, Papua and Ambon all sprung out the separatism group.. wanting to separate themself from Indonesia. Why? because they are not satisfied with the treatment they get from the government. Some said becasue the attention they get from the government are so little and make them felt like a neglected step child. Some times they longed to hear their name being mention or their named being written somewhere.

Now the question remain. What is the reason TIG include and emphasizing promt on Nationality entry?? until I get the answer then I will rest my case.



April 18, 2007 | 3:20 AM Comments  2 comments

Tags:
You must be logged in to add tags.


Comments

mfurdyk Michael Furdyk
April 18, 2007 | 4:02 AM
Welcome to TIG!
Hi Elena,

First of all, Welcome to TIG!

You should know that all fields in the profile are optional - you don't have to feel forced to fill out anything you don't want to choose.

Every day, we get many e-mails from TIG members wanting us to add languages, nationalities, schools, all kinds of items to the site. We have usually tried to develop as broad of a list as possible to keep everyone happy, but to also do our best to balance inclusivity with sensitivities around the globe.

I think the reason we specifically mention "Indonesian (incl Javanese/Sundanese/Sumatran)" is that in the past, people might have requested that their specific nationalities be added, but we thought that it didn't make sense to separate them, so instead we included them as a clarification under Indonesian. It's not meant to imply that they would be separate, but instead to assure them that they are included!

The other good news is that of course you're not restricted to only one nationality - you could have several. So we've tried to be open to accommodate these requests so that everyone can feel included.

I hope this is helpful, and I look forward to any other feedback you might have about any other things on TIG!

Did you know we have a country site for Indonesia? http://indonesia.takingitglobal.org/
matt85 Matt
April 18, 2007 | 6:16 AM

Selamat pagi :D

maybe some people don't know what to call themselves, they think they are Javanese when they are also Indonesian, but they like to be called Javanese.... sort of the same in New Zealand, where some people would rather be called "new zealander" than "new zealand european" even though its all one and the same (well to me at least)....
Helena Rijoly's Profile

Helena Rijoly's Friends


Latest Posts
They call me “Ma”
Three passions have...
WAITING BY THE SUNDOWN...
MEMIKIRKAN PERKAWINAN
Halfing the World (or...

Monthly Archive
April 2007
June 2007
July 2007

Change Language


Friends
Amy
Dabal Bista
Ephi Ong
harya
Madelaine Hamilton
mohamed elkashash
Shireen


4789 views
Important Disclaimer